Is the Narrator in Edgar Allan Poe's 'The Tell-Tale Heart' Insane: Critical Reflection Essay

Do you need this or any other assignment done for you from scratch?

We assure you a quality paper that is 100% free from plagiarism and AI.

You can choose either format of your choice ( Apa, Mla, Havard, Chicago, or any other)

NB: We do not resell your papers. Upon ordering, we do an original paper exclusively for you.

NB: All your data is kept safe from the public.

Is the Narrator in Edgar Allan Poe’s ‘The Tell-Tale Heart’ Insane: Critical Reflection Essay

The author intends to explain how the character rejects his mental state and appreciation of mortality. The character of The Tell-Tale Heart exhibits signs of mental issues through a series of events described by the author. In the short story, the narrator doubts his sanity from the beginning. He says, &but why will you say that I am mad? The disease had sharpened my senses not destroyed not dulled them. From the statement, it is evident that he is neglecting peoples sentiments and that he might be having psychological issues. However, he still acknowledges that he has a disease, but argues against medical or social intervention. He is in a psychotic state that disconnects him from normal thinking and real-life senses. He keeps asking himself numerous questions to validate that he is mentally stable and continually suppresses any external manifestation of the disease.

At one point, he says, I heard all things in the heaven and the earth. I heard many things in hell. The out-of-body experiences depict a possibility of dissociative disorder, which is also accompanied by emotional detachment. Additionally, he exhibits a dissociative identity disorder when he narrates the sounds in his mind and the rejection of himself. It is evident that this man has frequent derealization, such as escaping into the spiritual world and losing his sense of real life. This delirious act leads him to carry out many creepy intrusions into the old mans bedroom with unexplained intentions. He has been gaining access to the old mans room for several days to kill him.

It is evident from the story that the narrator struggles to maintain his sanity to the public, but things are different in his world. He is afraid of the old mans eye, which he perceives as evil. He is said to have left the old mans room several times when he realized the eye was gazing at him. It is due to the old mans eye that he plots and executes his heinous act. Even though he gains entry after several attempts, it is clear that he has struggled to attain this. He brags that he is a genius in his plan, which abnormally took him one hour to gain access through an opening, claiming it to be a genius action unlikely to be carried out by a madman. This description shows his disconnection from reality, a sign of mental illness. Later he kills the old man and tries to hide his actions, but he failed. At the beginning of the story, he alleges that he loves the old man. Later, he kills the man. Homicide is one of the main consequences of an acute mental disorder.

The change of actions and distorted reality exhibited by the loss of time justify his mental state of illness. He possibly has schizophrenia as he continually hears sounds ringing in his mind after the police probe him for the old mans whereabouts. He narrates that he is gaily of his actions; he thinks that killing the old man has made him heroic, but instead depicts his struggle to maintain sanity. Even though he purports to love the old mans character, he betrays the sentiment later in the story. The chronology of actions clearly shows that the character has entrenched mental issues, dissociating him from emotional consciousness. Even as the old man suffers before death, he can be seen celebrating his actions, the proof is his mental instability. He purports that the sounds of the old mans heartbeat sold him out to the police. He concludes by insulting the police officers, Villains!… here! It is the beating of his hideous heart!. He rejects the love for the old man and portrays him as having an unpleasant heart.

Thus, it is clear that the narrator is experiencing unnatural events and his act of murder justifies the need for clinical intervention in the state he rejects.

Work Cited

Poe, Edgar Allan, and Wolfgang Buchta. The Tell-Tale Heart. Wolfgang Buchta, 2002.

Click Here To Order Now!